← back to the Substrate Record

qid 1508 · law

Question: After a wife found out about her husband's infidelity, she decided to have him killed. The defendant approached a hit man to solicit his assistance in carrying out the planned murder. Although the wife believed that he was a hit man, he was, in fact, an undercover agent. The wife told the undercovr agent she would pay him $20,000 if he accepted the job and an additional $20,000 after the killing was completed. Upon hearing the wife's proposal, the undercover agent told the wife he would kill her husband. However, the undercover agent secretly intended not to go through with the plan, and he merely feigned agreement because he wished to trap the wife. The wife told the undercover agent that she would deliver the first payment the next day. However, before making the initial payment, the wife learned that the hit man was really an undercover agent. Fearful that she might be prosecuted for planning her husband's murder, the wife contacted the police and renounced her participation in the criminal endeavor. The defendant will most likely be found

  1. not guilty of either solicitation or conspiracy to commit murder.
  2. not guilty due to lack of intent.
  3. guilty of attempted murder.
  4. guilty of solicitation and conspiracy to commit murder.
  5. not guilty due to renouncing her participation.
  6. guilty of solicitation.
  7. guilty of conspiracy to commit murder and attempted murder.
  8. not guilty of conspiracy to commit murder, but guilty of solicitation.
  9. guilty of attempted murder and solicitation.
  10. guilty of conspiracy to commit murder.

Our answer: F. guilty of solicitation. Source quote machine-checked (at mint)

A machine check confirms the quoted words appear at the source. A person has not yet reviewed these. EARN MARKS as a Human Reviewer

How it was answered

Stored formula / worked method, replayed by code

Criminal law, inchoate offenses. Whether a solicitation survives the solicitee turning out to be an undercover agent, and whether a conspiracy can be formed with someone who only feigns agreement.

card: formula · card sha256 f6d1069933475a7c…

Current source

Model Penal Code Section 5.02(1), (2) and (3) (1962) -- criminal solicitation; uncommunicated solicitation; renunciation as an affirmative defense. Full text of the section verified for this dispatch.

Source weak (statute)

retrieved 2026-09-16T22:14:06.748Z

addendum formula_qid1508.formula_ADDENDUM_source · sha256 6c180080e0bb93f7…

If you have a Citable Source to dispute or challenge this, ADD IT so we can correct the answer by appending, never deleting. — hello@lianabanyan.com